Whats best Dead Mans shoes or This is England?

[spice]

Hello

I just love DMS got to be one of the best films ever.

Not seen This Is England yet But------------

Those who have seen both, what one do you thik is best, I guess they are both different films and maybe an impossible question, but just wondered

Cheers

Marcus

[Chewbaxter]

I'd say the best is "A Room For Romeo Brass".

N.

[Kezz]

for me its easy.. Dead mans shoes above all meadows films.. its phenominal.

This is England is great too,I'm extremely pleased with the outcome of that.. lol, but in completely honesty i think dms has the edge.
then i'd say twenty four seven.. its very clever in the sense it holds ur attention well when u think it would struggle to.
thn i'd say romeo.

[Hyde]

I'd say DMS and TiE are both as good as each other, very different, tell different stories but in the same style. Yknow?

then romeo brass and twentyfour seven for me

[carolyn]

I like DMS the most. It has so many social questions in it and makes me question myself and ask how I would behave in such circumstances.

[salvador]

Its DMS for me.

[Davros]

Personally Id say they were too different to be comparable. Which is a good thing I suppose, shows Shanes not knocking out a rehash of the last everytime. Cant wait to see TIE again though.

[Dazza]

Mmm Both are quality but my personal hitlist goes ARFRB (why does this one always seem so far down the list with fans) then DMS/TIE followed by 24/7

[RydCook]

TIE

[anonlytwin]

DMS

[RydCook]

anonlytwin said:

DMS

You're wrong

[jill]

Prove it.

[Dazza]

Taking away personal preferences and going by box office takings which film had the more success? I have a feeling its TIE but would be interesting to seee what would happen if DMS was released after as Shane wasnt as well known before.

[kimstone]

Defo Dead Man's Shoes...

[RydCook]

Ha ha, was only joking above! all to personal preference isn't it?!